This review originally appeared in Critics at Large
November 2. I include on this website because I wrote a chapter on the Cold War in That Line of Darkness: The Gothic from Lenin to bin Laden
(Encompass Editions, 2013).
 |
| Canadian diplomat Herbert Norman and his wife, Irene, in 1956 (Photo courtesy of UBC Library archives) |
In April 1957 the distinguished Canadian scholar and diplomat, Herbert
Norman, committed suicide by jumping from a roof in Cairo. Canadian-born
to missionaries working in Japan, he joined External Affairs in 1939,
and during the crazed atmosphere of the early 1950s, he was subjected to
a thorough security inquiry by the RCMP, largely because of his
left-wing sympathies when he attended Cambridge University during the
1930s. Even though he was vindicated, the Mounties passed on his file to
the FBI. His name came up in testimony before the Senate Internal
Security Subcommittee (SISS) and again he was given a clean billing. His
boss at External Affairs, Lester Pearson, appointed him as Ambassador
to Egypt to serve as a conduit between Gamal Abdel Nasser and the West
during the Suez Crisis. SISS revived the Norman “case” and to avoid
another humiliating security inquiry, Norman took his own life setting
off a firestorm of anti-American feelings in Canada.
In 1986 two purportedly scholarly books were published that were diametrically opposed in approach and conclusions:
Innocence Is Not Enough: The Life and Death of Herbert Norman by Roger Bowen and
No Sense of Evil: Espionage, The Case of Herbert Norman
by James Barros. The titles tell us much about the perspective of the
authors. Reviewers generally praised Bowen’s offering as a defence of
Norman’s integrity and explained his death as a response to the slanders
that he had to endure that left him with “no refuge but suicide.”
Barros’ thesis that Norman was an agent of the Soviet state “planted in
the Canadian diplomatic service” was largely excoriated. In the
Canadian Forum, Reg Whittaker reviled
No Sense of Evil
as a “disgrace to the best tradition of scholarly inquiry” because
Barros was not able to present a single piece of evidence to prove that
Norman engaged in espionage, was guilty of disloyalty or treason. Yet
the Norman controversy did not end here. Barros and MPs supportive of
his polemic put such pressure on the government to pursue an independent
inquiry that Joe Clark, then Minister for External Affairs, appointed
Peyton Lynn, a former diplomat and retired academic, to conduct an
investigation in which he was given access to all relevant documents.
His report completely exonerated Norman of any wrong doing and proclaimed him a loyal Canadian public servant.
This preamble is by way of introducing the absorbing
Mr. Jones
(Goose Lane, 2014), the most recent offering by the accomplished
Winnipeg dramatist, singer-lyricist and award winning novelist, Margaret
Sweatman. Herbert Norman is a minor character but his spirit hovers
throughout the novel to the extent that Emmet Jones becomes a
doppelganger to Norman. Sweatman does alter her profile of Jones to
alert the reader that he is not a carbon copy of Norman. For instance,
Emmet was pilot of the Bomber Command during the war that devastated
German cities, killing thousands of civilians. When he returns to Japan
to work for the External Affairs Department, his observations of a
fire-bombed burnt out post-war Tokyo trigger nightmares of his consuming
dead flesh. And his personal relationship with his wife Suzanne and
their young daughter, Lenora, perhaps the most intuitive character, is
fictional.